Blog

Weightlifting or Cardio: How to Know Which One Is Best for You

Walk into any gym and you’ll see two camps: the treadmill crowd and the weight room crowd. If you are trying to get healthier, lose weight or feel stronger, you may wonder which one is right for you. In the weightlifting or cardio debate, the honest answer is that both matter. The right mix depends on your goals.

Here is how they differ, what each one does best, and how to combine them.

What Is the Difference Between Weightlifting and Cardio?

Cardio

Cardio (aerobic exercise) raises your heart rate for a sustained period. Walking, cycling, swimming, rowing and running are all cardio. It builds endurance, strengthens your heart and lungs and burns calories while you do it. How many depends on your size and how hard you work.

Weightlifting

Weightlifting (resistance training) works your muscles against a load in shorter, harder efforts, using machines, free weights, bands or your own body weight. It builds strength and muscle, supports bone health and helps your body use energy better. Hard sessions also keep your metabolism slightly raised for a while afterward, sometimes called the “afterburn” effect.

Dr. Scott Gray using hands-on treatment on a patient's neck

Which One Is Best for Your Goal?

  • Weight loss: both. Cardio burns calories now; muscle from lifting helps you keep weight off. Nutrition matters most of all.
  • Heart health and endurance: cardio leads, with lifting as a partner.
  • Strength, bone health and staying independent: weightlifting leads, especially after 50.
  • Joint pain: both, with low impact cardio and carefully chosen strength exercises.

Guidelines for adults recommend at least 150 minutes of moderate cardio a week plus strength training at least 2 days a week (Piercy et al., 2018).

The Principles That Apply to Both

  • Stimulus: progress comes from challenging your body a little more over time.
  • Adaptation: your body adjusts to what you do, so a routine that never changes stops working.
  • Recovery: sleep, nutrition and rest days are when you actually get fitter.
  • Consistency: regular, moderate effort beats occasional hard workouts.

Tips for Effective Workouts

  1. Warm up: 5 to 10 minutes of easy movement prepares your body (see the best warmups before strength training).
  2. Progress gradually: add a little time, distance or weight at a time.
  3. Rest: between hard sets and between hard days.
  4. Hydrate: especially in Florida heat and humidity.
  5. Listen to your body: stop if you feel dizzy, short of breath or sharp pain.
  6. Cool down: finish with easy movement and stretching.

A Simple Weekly Mix

Try 2 to 3 full-body strength sessions and 2 to 3 cardio sessions a week, or combine them in circuits. Not sure about lifting? Start with strength training for beginners.

When to Check With Your Doctor

Talk to your doctor before starting if you have a heart or lung condition, high blood pressure or diabetes. Stop and seek care for chest pain, dizziness or unusual shortness of breath.

Research

  • Piercy, K. L., et al. (2018). The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans. JAMA, 320(19), 2020-2028. PubMed

Everything we do follows The Gray Method™: find the cause, fix it, then build you up so it stays fixed.

Get the Right Mix for Your Goals

Our personal training in Fort Myers balances strength and cardio for your body and your goals, with degreed, certified coaches who specialize in adults 50+ and work alongside our Doctors of Physical Therapy.

Not sure where to start? Our Free Fit-After-50 Assessment is about 30 minutes, one-on-one, with a gentle movement screen and a personal roadmap. No cost, no pressure, no contracts.

Call our office at (239) 223-0484 to schedule your assessment.

About the Author: Ashley Gray

Ashley Gray
Free book Fixing the Cause & Not Just the Symptoms by Dr. Scott Gray

Get Dr. Gray's Best-Selling Book, Free

Why pain keeps coming back, and how The Gray Method™ helps you fix it for good.

Send Me the Free Book
Ready for answers?

Talk to a Doctor of Physical Therapy

★★★★★ 4.9/5 from 180+ reviews

One-on-one care that finds the cause of your pain. Fort Myers, Cape Coral & Estero.

Inquire About an Appointment Or call (239) 223-0484