Three Conditions That Mimic Sciatica
Have you searched your symptoms online and decided you have sciatica? Not so fast. Sciatica causes pain, numbness or tingling that travels from the lower back down the back of the leg, but it isn’t the only condition that does that.
Several other problems can feel almost exactly like sciatica, and they need a completely different treatment. If you’ve tried sciatica stretches and home remedies without relief, you may be treating the wrong problem. Here’s how to tell the difference.
What Is Sciatica?
Sciatica is irritation of the sciatic nerve, the large nerve that starts in the lower back, runs through the buttock and travels down the back of the leg. When the nerve is compressed, inflamed or entrapped, you may feel:
- Pain that travels from the lower back or buttock down the back of the leg, often stopping around the calf
- Numbness or tingling along the same path
- Symptoms on one side of the body
- Pain that ranges from a mild annoyance to something that stops you in your tracks
Common causes include a herniated disc or a bone spur pressing on the nerve, or the nerve getting pinched by tight muscles such as the piriformis or hamstrings. Strictly speaking, sciatica is a set of symptoms, not a diagnosis. The real question is what is irritating the nerve.
Which Conditions Mimic Sciatica?
These three conditions are the ones we see confused with sciatica most often in our Fort Myers and Cape Coral clinics.
1. Joint Conditions (Like Spinal Arthritis)
Your lower back has small joints called facet joints, just like the joints in your knees or elbows. When they’re irritated or worn down, for example from arthritis, they can cause pain that spreads into the buttock and leg.
- Clue: joint pain is more often a dull ache, without numbness or tingling running all the way down to the calf.
- But: not everyone with true sciatica has numbness or tingling, so a proper exam is the only reliable way to tell them apart.
2. Piriformis Syndrome
Does your pain, tingling or numbness seem to start in the buttock rather than the lower back? It may be piriformis syndrome. The piriformis is a muscle deep in the buttock, and the sciatic nerve runs right next to it. When the muscle tightens or spasms, it irritates the nerve.
Treatment focuses on why the muscle is overworking, combined with stretching, strengthening and hands-on soft tissue work.
3. Sacroiliac (SI) Joint Dysfunction
The SI joint connects the bottom of your spine to your pelvis. When it moves too much (hypermobility) or too little, it can cause pain low in the back that spreads into the buttock and leg, and it can feel just like sciatica.
- Too little motion: hands-on joint mobilization and mobility exercises help.
- Too much motion: stability exercises help, and an SI belt may be useful during activity.
Learn more in is your back pain stemming from your SI joint?
Other Conditions That Can Feel Like Sciatica
- Hip bursitis or gluteal tendinopathy: a dull ache on the outside of the hip, often worse with sitting, walking or lifting the leg out to the side.
- Hip joint problems: groin pain with long walks, deep squats or twisting can point to the hip joint itself, for example arthritis or a labral tear.
- Spinal stenosis: narrowing around the nerves that’s usually worse with standing and walking, and better with sitting.
How Will My Doctor Tell the Difference?
A Doctor of Physical Therapy uses your history and a series of hands-on tests to pinpoint the source:
- Straight leg raise: you lie on your back while we slowly lift your leg. Where and when the pain starts helps separate sciatica from conditions that mimic it.
- Slump test: you sit slouched while we straighten your knee and pull your foot up, putting gentle tension on the sciatic nerve. If this brings on your back, buttock or hamstring symptoms, it points toward true sciatica.
- Piriformis test: we bend your knee and bring your leg up and across your body to put tension on the piriformis.
- SI joint tests: such as the distraction test (pressing on the front of the hips), the FABER test (moving the bent leg out to the side) and the sacral thrust (pressing on the back of the pelvis while you lie face down). Pain with more than one of these points toward the SI joint.
- Strength, reflex and sensation checks to see whether a nerve is involved.
X-rays and MRIs can show whether something is pressing on a nerve, such as a herniated disc or bone spur, and can show arthritis. But imaging isn’t always needed to make a diagnosis, and it can’t always tell you what’s actually causing your pain.
When to See a Doctor Right Away
- Loss of bladder or bowel control, or numbness in the groin or inner thighs
- Leg weakness that is getting worse, or foot drop
- Leg pain with fever, unexplained weight loss or a history of cancer
Getting the Right Treatment
Pain, numbness and tingling down the leg are alarming, but most of the conditions that cause them are very treatable once you know what you’re dealing with. At Back In Motion, we pinpoint which condition you have and what caused it, then treat that cause with hands-on care, joint mobilization and a personalized exercise plan.
See how our sciatica relief program works, and read what’s the best way to treat sciatica for what to expect.
Frequently Asked Questions
What can be mistaken for sciatica?
The most common are facet joint problems such as arthritis, piriformis syndrome, SI joint dysfunction, hip bursitis or tendinopathy, hip joint problems and spinal stenosis.
How do I know if it’s sciatica or my hip?
Hip problems often cause pain on the outside of the hip or in the groin, especially with walking, squatting or twisting. True sciatica usually runs down the back of the leg, often with tingling or numbness. An exam is the best way to know for sure.
Can a physical therapist diagnose sciatica?
Yes. A Doctor of Physical Therapy can run the tests above to find the source of your symptoms, and will refer you for imaging or to a physician when it’s needed.
Find Out What’s Really Causing Your Leg Pain
Start with our Fixing the Cause & Not Just the Symptoms Assessment, or Inquire About an Appointment →
Call our office at (239) 223-0484 to schedule your appointment.
Get Dr. Gray's Best-Selling Book, Free
Why pain keeps coming back, and how The Gray Method™ helps you fix it for good.
Send Me the Free BookOur Most-Read Articles
- 1Three Conditions That Mimic Sciatica PainBack
- 2The Great Plantar Fasciitis Debate: Why Boots & Cortisone Rarely Fix ItFoot
- 3Common Causes of Lower Back Pain: Herniated DiscBack
- 4The 3 Most Common Symptoms of Knee Meniscal TearsKnee
- 5What Is Hip Bursitis?Hip
- 6Pelvic Pain Explained: When It's Not a UTI but Feels Like OnePelvic
What Do You Need Help With?
- 🩺Back, neck & joint pain→
- 💪Fitness for adults 50+→
- 💙Pelvic health→
- ⚡Sports performance→
- ⛳Golf performance→
Talk to a Doctor of Physical Therapy
One-on-one care that finds the cause of your pain. Fort Myers, Cape Coral & Estero.
Inquire About an Appointment Or call (239) 223-0484





